Rose Library - Cleveland Community College

DVD/VHS Commercially Produced Material in Library Collection

Deficiency 
Some Library owned video material is not captioned. 

Correction
Recommendations

1. Develop and implement plan for correcting all commercially produced material that is not currently captioned. 

2. Discontinue purchasing non-captioned material.

Support

Priority
Individual items for captioning have been prioritized as high, medium, low in Correction of Library Owned Non-captioned Video Material Five Year Plan and associated documentation

Cost
Captioning of commercially produced materials will be processed by the Helpdesk as requested by the instructor.   This will be performed in house and will incur minimal cost.  Professional captioning services will only be used in critical need situations.

Oversite
Barbara McKibbin

Finalized Actions/Date
1. Correction of Library Owned Non-captioned Video Material Five Year Plan published and implementation begun April 2014

2. Permission to captions requests sent to copyright holders for non-captioned commercial DVDs and VHS tapes used by faculty June 2014.  Permissions will be retained until captioning for these items is required.  

Back to Contents

Instructor Produced Video Material Currently Available to Students

Deficiency 

Lack of captioning on most items. Videos that need additional aural information for visually impaired students may be lacking this information.  

Correction
Recommendations

1. All instructor created videos  in classes with a hearing impaired student must be captioned as soon as the instructor is informed of the hearing impaired student's enrollment in the class.

2. All instructor created videos must have an appropriate aural description if this is necessary for understanding by any visually impaired person as soon as the instructor is informed of the visually impaired student's  enrollment  in the class.   

3. All  instructor created  videos used for instruction for more than one term must be captioned as of August 1, 2015. 

Support

  • Resources for captioning will be identified and/ or purchased and appropriate processes will be established by August 1, 2014. 
  • Appropriate training sessions  for faculty will be provided, beginning in August 2014. 
  • Appropriate support documentation will be available by August 1, 2014.

Priority
High

Cost
Most captioning will be done by Helpdesk staff.  Cost for one Helpdesk assistant per year for managing captioning processes will be approximately $12,500.  Site license for Synchrimedia Movie Captioner software   $1,440.00 

Oversite

1. & 2. Disability Coordinator informs faculty member that captions or transcripts are necessary; Disability Coordinator contacts Dean of Learning Resources regarding all students who qualify for accommodations

3. Appropriate Learning Resources Staff (to be determined) will evaluate all online and hybrid courses for  four newly added accessibility criteria and report needed corrections to Academic Dean during fall 2015; this criteria includes  "The course contains equivalent alternatives to auditory and visual content" with reference to captioning

Finalized Actions/Date

Technology Helpdesk staff, some Library and AV personnel, and some other campus clerical staff were trained on MovieCaptioner June/July 2014. Processes were established for faculty to request captioning of video July 2014 with appropriate documentation. Faculty received instruction on processes for having items captioned at mandatory Learning Center workshops on August 13, 15, and 21 (Adjuncts) 2014.  See "Video Captioning" section of Other Library Services. Modifications have been made to the process as necessary.  

Back to Contents

New Instructor Produced Video Material

Deficiency 
Captioning newly created multimedia items has not been the practice. Items in production will probably not contain captions until current practices are changed.

Correction
Recommendation

1. All new instructor created video material must be captioned before being published for  students beginning Fall Term 2014.  

Support

  • Training sessions will be provided for faculty  beginning Fall Term 2014.  
  • Appropriate support documentation will be available by August 1, 2014.
  • Resources for captioning will be identified and/ or purchased and appropriate processes will be established by August 1, 2014. 

Priority
High

Cost

Most captioning will be done by Helpdesk staff.  Cost for one Helpdesk assistant per year for managing captioning processes will be approximately $12,500. 

Oversite

Appropriate College Staff (to be determined) will evaluate all online and hybrid courses for four accessibility criteria and report needed corrections to Academic Dean during fall 2015; this criteria includes  "The course contains equivalent alternatives to auditory and visual content" with reference to captioning .  Dean will be responsible for working with faculty to correct all non-captioned items.

Finalized Actions/Date

Faculty received instruction on processes for having items captioned at mandatory Learning Center workshops on August 13, 15, and 21 (Adjuncts) 2014.  As of December 2014 only materials that require captioning because a deaf or hard of hearing student is enrolled in class have been sent for captioning.   

Back to Contents

File Attachments in Blackboard and Email

Deficiency 
File attachments in Blackboard and email are not being evaluated for screen reader accessibility.  As a result, some are accessible and some are not. 

Correction
Recommendations

1. All new instructor created files used in Blackboard, emailed to students, or posted on websites must be screen reader accessible beginning 2015 Spring Term.  For classes with a visually impaired student this must be done immediately upon learning of the student's enrollment in the class.  

2. All existing files must be assessed for readability and, if necessary, replaced with a  readable version of the file by the beginning of 2015 Summer Term.  For classes with a visually impaired student this must be done immediately upon learning of the student's enrollment in the class.   

3.  Training on creation of accessible documents for a core support group should be conducted during 2014 Summer Term.  

Support

  • Instruction on  creating accessible documents will be included in workshops delivered 2014 Fall Term.  
  • Appropriate support documentation will be available by August 1, 2014.
  •  On December 1, 2014 Administrative Council determined that online training  needs to be developed or added to the current MIT course for adjunct faculty and others who cannot attend training sessions or need additional support.   The training needs to include everything covered by the training sessions VLC will deliver on February 5, 2015.   

Priority
High

Cost
Have scheduled training to be conducted by representatives from VLC which will not incur costs.   Will identify other training alternatives if further training is necessary.

Oversite
Appropriate College Staff (to be determined) will evaluate all online and hybrid courses for four accessibility criteria and report needed corrections to Academic Dean during Fall 2015; this criteria includes  "The course design accommodates the use of assistive technologies employed by the college or commonly used by students with disabilities such as screen readers, text to audio scanners, speech to text software, etc."  Dean will be responsible for working with faculty to implement corrections to their documents.

Finalized Actions/Date

Training on creating accessible documents, presentations, websites, and course sites will be conducted by VLC staff on February 6, 2015.   Administrative Council determined that this will be mandatory for all full-time faculty and will be available for all other employees, including adjunct faculty.  

Back to Contents

Audio Files in Blackboard

Deficiency 
Most audio files do not have a transcript for hearing impaired students.

Correction
Recommendations

1. All instructor created audio used in classes with a hearing impaired student must be accompanied by a transcript as soon as the instructor is informed of the hearing impaired student's enrollment in the class.

2. All audio files to be used for more than one term must be accompanied by a transcript as of August 1, 2015.

Support

  • Appropriate training sessions will be provided in August 2014. 
  • Appropriate support documentation will be available by August 1, 2014.

Priority
High

Cost

None

Oversite

Appropriate College staff (to be determined) will evaluate all online and hybrid courses for four accessibility criteria and report needed corrections to Academic Dean during fall 2015; this criteria includes  "The course contains equivalent alternatives to auditory and visual content" with reference to accessible text file alternatives for all audio.  Deans will be responsible for working with faculty to correct all non-compliant items. N/A

Finalized Actions/Date

N/A

Back to Contents

Publisher Websites and Course Cartridges Used for Course Content

Deficiency 
For accessibility statements from currently used publisher content see:

CENGAGE -  (for SAM)

PARADIGM  -  (for SNAP)

PEARSON  -  (for Mastering BIO)

ELSEVIER  -   (for OST)

MACMILLAN  -  (for ENG classes)

Correction
Recommendations

1.  Any existing online presentations used for instruction will be modified for appropriate accessibility immediately when the instructor is aware that a disabled student is enrolled in the class.

2.  All new online presentations used for instruction for more than one term will have accessible features or alternatives beginning January 1, 2015. 

Support

  • Directions for creating accessible online presentations will be available to faculty by August 1, 2014. 
  • Instruction on  creating accessible presentations will be included in workshops delivered 2014 Fall Term.

Priority
High

Cost
None

Oversite
Academic Deans

Finalized Actions/Dates
The online course template has been modified to include links to publisher accessibility statements within the "Instructor Resources" folder.  Instructions are provided to faculty that they should select the appropriate publisher accessibility link and post it on the syllabus page and under "Access and Accomodations" in the Contact Information section of their course.  If the appropriate link is not provided in the course template instructions are given for locating appropriate information.    

Back to Contents

Instructor Added Content, Formatting, and Structure in Blackboard and on Instructor Websites Used for Instruction

Deficiency 
Instructors have not been given guidance on complying with accessibility  standards for online content creation.  As a result, elements of many courses are not currently compliant.

Correction
Recommendations

1. Four accessibility standards will be added to the College online / hybrid course evaluation rubric for evaluation of all new courses beginning 2015 Spring Term.   

2.  All new courses will be compliant with the stated accessibility standards for 2015 Spring Term.  

3. All current courses will be evaluated based on the stated accessibility standards in 2016 Summer term.  

Support

  • Beginning 2014 Fall Term, workshops will be conducted each term to guide all faculty on creating more accessible courses. 
  • Appropriate support documentation will be available August 1, 2014.
  • Additional course accessibility instruction will be added to MIT 110 for 2014 Fall Term.  On December 1, 2014 Administrative Council determined that online training  needs to be developed or added to the current MIT course for adjunct faculty and others who cannot attend training sessions or need additional support. The training needs to include everything covered by the training sessions.  Representative from the Virtual Learning Community (VLC) will deliver an introduction and overview on course accessibility on February 5, 2015.

Priority
High

Cost
College already pays for outside evaluator.  There will be no added costs for evaluating accessibility compliance.

Oversite
Report from outside evaluator goes to Deans; Deans meet with faculty regarding any issues, which could include accessibility issues. 

Finalized Actions/Dates
N/A

Back to Contents

College Website

Deficiency 
As of 2014/04/15 the website has some accessibility issues.

Correction
Recommendations

1. Four accessibility standards will be added to the College online / hybrid course evaluation rubric for evaluation of all new courses beginning 2015 Spring Term.   

2.  All new courses will be compliant with the stated accessibility standards for 2015 Spring Term.  

3. All current courses will be evaluated based on the stated accessibility standards in 2016 Summer term.  

Support

  • Beginning 2014 Fall Term, workshops will be conducted each term to guide all faculty on creating more accessible courses. 
  • Appropriate support documentation will be available August 1, 2014.
  • Additional course accessibility   instruction will be added to MIT 110 for 2014 Fall Term.

Priority
Medium

Cost
For meeting WCAG standards, there is no additional cost to the College since we already have SiteImprove to scan for accessibility issues based on WCAG criteria.  

AIM certification  costs nothing; there are costs for an initial scan and other scans to check for error corrections.   Using SiteImprove to its potential will reduce this. 

Oversite
Public Information and Marketing Coordinator 

Finalized Actions/Dates
College webmaster has used SiteImprove to continue to scan,  make improvements, and ensure the College site conforms to WCAG 2.0 and Section 508 during Fall 2014.  He also completed the Web Accessibility Certification course offered through SiteImprove in October 2014. 

Back to Contents

Library Website

Deficiency 
Technically, the Library website, created with LibGuides,  is compliant by providing a text-only version.  Site is not easily accessible with a screen reader.

Correction
Recommendations

1. Complete migration to LibGuides 2.0 

Priority

Medium

Cost
None

Oversite
Barbara McKibbin,until summer 2017, then Jerrianne Queen

Finalized Actions/Dates
Migration to LibGuides 2.0 completed Summer 2014. Website redesign in 2017 by Verified Studios. Website is checked weekly by Site Improve Accessibility Checker. Changes made if needed.

Back to Contents

Ellucian Portal 4.0/Sharepoint 2013

Deficiency
Compliant with possible exceptions in custom programming. 

Correction
Recommendations

Ellucian Portal is compliant as it comes out of the box, custom programming and enhancements can create accessibility issues. Enhancements should be minimized and checked for compliance before publication.  

Support

  • Ellucian Portal documentation

Priority
Medium

Cost
None

Oversite
Howard Roberts/Technology Committee 

Finalized Actions/Dates
N/A

Back to Contents

Blackboard Interface

Deficiency
Compliant

Correction
None needed

Priority
High

Cost
None

Oversite
Distance Learning Coordinator/Instructional Development Coordinator 

Finalized Actions/Dates
N/A

Back to Contents

Online Presentation Software

Deficiency
Most online presentations currently in use are not compliant.  

Corrections
Recommendations

1.  Any existing online presentations used for instruction will be modified for appropriate accessibility immediately when the instructor is aware that a disabled student is enrolled in the class.

2.  All new online presentations used for instruction for more than one term will have accessible features or alternatives beginning January 1, 2015. 

Support

  • Directions for creating accessible online presentations will be available to faculty by August 1, 2014. 
  • Instruction on  creating accessible presentations will be included in workshops delivered 2014 Fall Term.

Priority
High

Cost
None

Oversite
Any non-compliant resources will be reported to Academic Deans through reports from outside course evaluator.

Finalized Actions/Dates
Training on creating accessible documents, presentations, websites, and course sites will be conducted by VLC staff on February 6, 2015.   Administrative Council determined that this will be mandatory for all full-time faculty and will be available for all other employees, including adjunct faculty.    

Back to Contents

Web-based Instruction Applications Used in Any Course

Deficiency
Accessibility Statements for Current Web-based Applications: 

MyMathLab: http://www.pearsonmylabandmastering.com/northamerica/mymathlab/accessibility/
WebAssign: http://www.webassign.net/manual/instructor_guide/c_a_accessibility.htm
Connect: http://connect.mcgraw-hill.com/help/instructor/#id=02nC0000000HHJW&type=category
Pearson Writer: http://www.pearsonhighered.com/educator/accessibility/index.page

Correction
Recommendations:

1. Any online instruction product evaluated for purchase/adoption after July 1, 2014 should be evaluated with accessibility as one criteria. 

2. Instructors should provide accessibility information regarding required online applications to students through the online course "Accessibility Statement" and/or the course syllabus beginning August 1, 2014.  

Support

  •  A "Statement of Accessibility" section will be added to the Blackboard Course template for 2014 Fall Term courses.  

Priority
High

Cost
None

Oversite
Academic Deans; Distance Learning Coordinator

Finalized Actions/Dates
The online course template has been modified to include links to publisher accessibility statements within the "Instructor Resources" folder.  Instructions are provided to faculty that they should select the appropriate publisher accessibility link and post it on the syllabus page and under "Access and Accommodations" in the Contact Information section of their course.  If the appropriate link is not provided in the course template instructions are given for locating appropriate information.

Back to Contents

AccuTrak (Tutoring)

Deficiency 
Not compliant 

Correction
Scheduling for students is accommodated by students  requesting assistance from a staff member in the Student Success Center.

Priority
Medium

Cost
None

Oversite
Director, Student Success Center

Finalized Actions/Dates
N/A

Back to Contents

MyCleveland

Deficiency
Compliant-- works with a screen reader. See https://webadvisor.yccd.edu/WebAdvisor/html/accessibility.html

Correction
None needed

Priority
High

Cost
None

Oversite
Director, Student Success Center

Finalized Actions/Dates
N/A

Back to Contents

Student Email

Deficiency

Correction
Recommendation

1. Information on email accessibility will be included in all email support documentation provided to students.  For online documents this information should be added for 2014 Summer Term.  For printed documentation this should be with the next printing.

Priority
High

Cost
None

Oversite
Kyle Harmon/Athena Smith

Finalized Actions/Date
N/A

Back to Contents

AskCleve

Deficiency
According to intelliresponse.com: IR-hosted answer page framework is ADA-compliant
Content can be created to meet accessibility standards as applicable. (For example, embedded URLs can be displayed full to support screen readers.)

Correction
Recommendation

1. Content created by the College and added to Ask Cleve should meet accessibility standards as applicable. This needs further examination.

Priority
Medium/Low

Cost
None

Oversite
Vice-President Student Services

Finalized Actions/Date
N/A

Back to Contents

Library Databases

Deficiency 
Compliance information available at Accessible Library Services

Correction
Recommendation:

1. Maintain compliance documentation/ information on Library website

Priority
High

Cost
None

Oversite
Barbara McKibbin

Finalized Actions/Dates
N/A

Back to Contents

eBooks

Deficiency 
Compliance information located at http://library.clevelandcc.edu/home/accessiblelibraryservices

Correction
Recommendation:

1. Maintain compliance documentation/ information on Library website

Priority
High

Cost
None

Oversite
Barbara McKibbin

Finalized Actions/Dates
N/A

Back to Contents

Library Catalog (CCLINC)

Deficiency
For SirsiDynix accessibility statement see: http://www.sirsidynix.com/accessibility

Correction

Recommendation:

1. Maintain compliance documentation/ information on Library website

Priority
High

Cost
None

Oversite
Barbara McKibbin

Finalized Actions/Dates
N/A

Back to Contents

Placement Tests

Deficiency 
Not complaint

Correction
Compass is not compliant but will be replaced with Accuplacer during Summer 2014 Term.  Accuplacer is compliant.  Braille tests for all placement tests have been ordered.

Priority 
High

Cost
Already purchased

Oversite
Director, Student Success Center

Finalized Actions/Dates
N/A

Back to Contents

Instructor Websites

Deficiency 
Some instructor websites contain uncaptioned videos and file attachments that might not be screen reader accessible.  

Correction
Recommendation: 

1. Any instructor website necessary for instruction must comply with standards established for Blackboard instructor added  content, file attachments, video captioning, audio file transcripts, and online / hybrid course accessibility standards on the timeframe for those items.  
2. All instructor websites should be assessed for compliance in conjunction with and on the schedule of the College website.

Support

  • Website accessibility workshops will be provided to all interested faculty during 2014-15 academic year. 

Priority 
High/Medium

Cost
None

Oversite
Academic Deans, Public Information and Marketing Coordinator

Finalized Actions/Dates
N/A

Back to Contents

Overall Compliance

Deficiency 
Taskforce recommends going forward with all corrections, with appropriate oversight.  

Correction
Recommendations:

1. Adopt and implement all recommended corrections, with appropriate oversight.
2. Create a standing Accessibility Committee. 

Priority 
High

Cost
Costs will be for captioning software, support staff, and outside services if necessary; outside evaluator for online course accessibility; training; website certification

Oversite
Accessibility Committee and Learning Resources Accessibility Taskforce

Finalized Actions/Dates
In May 2014 the College Administrative Council appointed a permanent Accessibility Committee.  Members of the Committee will be HR & Safety Manager (chair), Director Physical Plant, CIO, Dean Learning Resources, Director  Student Success Center, Webmaster, Financial Aid Coordinator, 1 faculty member appointed by Faculty Senate.   The President recommended that the Learning Resources Accessibility Taskforce continue to meet to monitor this plan.  

Back to Contents